We have tried it and we like it. Natural Impulse is our first experience using handmade soap. Hubby likes Bay Rum. I'm enjoying Too Sexy for my Soap. It's supposed to be irresistible to men but I haven't experienced that as my husband hasn't stopped smelling himself. We are a fragrant couple -- but in a good way, lol.
Scratch that--my husband just noticed the scent. I think he likes it.
Edited to add: I chose Too Sexy for my Soap because I absolutely love the smell, not because of its reported male-irresistibility properties. So when I wrote the above, it just tickled me how my husband was enjoying his Bay Rum scent. He's a "manly man" so I never would have imagined he would take to a bar of soap like he has.